You need a new Direct Import Provider

After weeks of issues with your Direct Import Provider being able to import from some of the largest banks I'm putting forth the idea that it's time to reconsider your Import Provider.  In short, they are failing to deliver on the product as intended.

Similarly, YNAB is failing to deliver on their product as advertised.  While bank importing has been around for years, your current implementation is largely a failure and you have to either, reconfigure your pricing to reflect a reduction in services available for reconsider the relationship you have with the Direct Importers.

Considering that Direct Import is a rather common offering, advertising this and failing to deliver is an indication that, as a company, you have your attention elsewhere or lack the resources to address a core functionality.  This doesn't look good.

This is beyond annoying.  If you simply removed the expectation that Direct Import could happen it would be far simpler for the customer to come to terms with that and act accordingly.

13replies Oldest first
  • Oldest first
  • Newest first
  • Active threads
  • Popular
  • We're closing out Bank Importing threads in the forum to make sure these issues are better resolved.

    Replies in this thread have been turned off, but you can still suggest new banks (even international banks) in the app, if you haven’t already!

    If you’re having trouble connecting to a bank in the US or Canada, please fill out this form and our Direct Import team will help you get things back up and running!

  • Unfortunately, I agree.   YNAB is an outstanding product.

    But Direct Import is giving the product a negative impression.  Something that used to work perfectly is now painful.

    Yodlee perhaps as the new DirectImport provider?

    • Cadet Blue Wizard Moving import partners isn't always the answer. We're on our third, and have a bit of experience here. 😉 When banks make changes to their platform, our import partner has to make some significant changes on their side to re-establish a connection and import transactions.

      If you have a moment, would you mind submitting a Feature Request to let our team know you'd like us to look into Yodlee? At this time, we aren't searching for a new partner—but I never say never. Quovo, our current partner was recently acquired by Plaid, and we're excited to see where it goes.

      If you have a particular bank connection you'd like us to look at, please let me know!

  • Hi Cadet Blue Nomad ! I'm moving this over to our Bank Importing section for a better fit.

    When we launched the online version of YNAB, we had one Direct Import partner. We have since added two more in order to provide more stable support for a wider range of financial institutions, improve connection stability, and improve response times.

    I'm sorry to hear you've been having connection troubles. There are many moving parts with direct import and any little (or big!) change from the banks can cause disruptions in the connection. If you'd like us to look closer at a particular connection of yours, please let me know.

    While direct import is a really amazing feature (especially when it's working!), we feel our method is strong enough that your budget can still work very well without it. In fact, lots of YNABers don't use direct import at all and they're still able to have and use an awesome budget.

    That said, we are actively working to make this less of a pain point for users (and for us too, since we're all YNABers ourselves!). We're constantly exploring options with existing and new data providers to help with that. Direct import is something we do want to provide as a dependable feature!

    Let me know if you have any questions!

  • My direct import has been solid for a very long time.  I currently have capital one requesting a code on a regular basis but that is capital one's issue and not ynab's.  Seriously all the direct import whiners should move to the service they think has that great direct import capability with no problems.  Oh yeah...that's right, i think i know why they'd rather just whine on here. 

    Like 1
    • Herman thanks for the constructive commentary, it really helps foster a community.

      Like 3
    • Cadet Blue Nomad This guy literally spams here and reddit all day every day blaming everyone other than YNAB themselves. Pretty clearly an employee with too much free time and too little character to use his/her real name.

  • Herman You are incorrect. I'm trying out two competing products to YNAB and neither are experiencing any import issues. The two other products are from larger companies which might be one reason however  I agree with Cadet Blue Nomad that something needs to change. I've been singing praises about YNAB for 5+ years but the import issues alone will drive me to a competing platform unless things get better. 

    Like 1
  • It has been almost a month since my institution was able to sync which has effectively made YNAB worthless.  I would hope that YNAB could offer some sort of reimbursement to offset the fact that we just paid them for nothing.  Also, why is there no way to import transactions manually?   This is one of the simplest solutions to have as a backup when issues come up and it was in the original app version but not the online version.  I have had to spend almost 10 hours this month manually adding every transaction so I can actually see where my budget is at.  I love the product but there is something seriously wrong with the import providers because either you or they are in breach of SLA contracts.  You better hurry up before this turns into a class actionable issue.

    Like 1
    • Hi Silver Wildcat !

      Sorry for the trouble you've been experiencing with direct import! I took a look and all of your account connections are currently showing as successful. Are you able to connect but new transactions aren't importing? If that's the case, let me know which bank you're having trouble with and we can take a closer look at things!

      In the meantime, we do offer manual import in the online version of YNAB, just like we did in YNAB 4. You can use File-Based Importing by downloading a QIF, QFX or CSV file from your bank. 

      Also, we take security very seriously, and we make sure to stay up to date on all codes and requirements.

    • Faness Thank you for pointing out the documentation for uploading transactions.  This feature could probably use a little more information on the main app because I had not idea it existed.  My bank is America First Credit Union.  The status shows connected but it only see's my checking and savings.  It does not pull new transactions and it does not see any of the other loans or accounts like it use to so all of those are unlinked.  Also, SLA stands for Service Level Agreement and has nothing to do with security.  I would hope that security is top on the list and that YNAB is PCI certified since you are dealing with financial institutions and transactions.  Again, thanks for pointing out the manual upload.

    • Hi Silver Wildcat ! Our import partner is working on the America First Credit Union connection, after their recent platform updates.

      We've seen some progress, and the connection has been restored—but we are hearing reports that transactions aren't importing or that some accounts might be missing (like you mentioned). There is definitely more work to be done, and we'll keep at it! You can find the latest news on the status page.

  • Direct import using the open banking standard should be added as soon as possible, that your current partner is unable to and as we see, the same partner has issues elsewhere, should probably steer you towards a new partner?

    Like 1
Replies are closed
  • 13 days agoLast active
  • 13Replies closed
  • 242Views
  • 11 Following